Attorney Michael de Broglio on: South Africa, Law, Politics, Attorneys, Sport, Photography, Technology, Gadgets, Media, Crime, Road Accidents Fund,
Divorce, Maintenance, Personal Injury, Medical Negligence
There are no easy answers to the annexation of Crimea, but I do think that the Western powers have involved themselves in a fight they won't win. It suited many of them, on many different occasions, to hold referendums to allow people to determine their fate. Now that the Crimeans held a referendum in their country, where the result was always a foregone conclusion, everybody slates it as being illegal and unconstitutional. It looks worse once you have seen a 96% result by the Crimeans in favour of joining Russia. The fact of the matter is that Crimea has a very complicated history and while Ukraine was part of the USSR, Crimea was given by Russia to the Ukraine. It only happened approximately 50 years ago and so it is certainly not the case that Crimea has been a part of Ukraine, while Ukraine has been an independent country, for all eternity!
Ukraine is a relatively new country, once it broke away from the USSR, and the vast majority of people that live in Crimea are in fact Russians. I don’t feel particularly strongly about the issue because on the one hand we cannot have all people, living in different areas of the world, having votes all the time to decide which country they form a part of, but on the other hand the result is overwhelming and it would seem to make little sense to force the people to remain within the Ukraine if clearly they do not want to be – however valuable that land is of course to Ukraine. On the other hand, I really don’t think that the issue is serious enough, given the history of Crimea as well as how the votes have gone, for the European powers as well as America who obviously have a cold war history with Russia, to start threatening sanctions, etc. One has to see Ukraine in the proper perspective and that is that its whole yearly GDP is worth less than the Walt Disney company share on the New York Stock Exchange. Nobody is getting murdered, there is not ethnic cleansing going on and all that has happened is that people living in an area, have decided that they want to form a part of the country that they always belonged to in the past in any event, namely Russia.
For the Western powers and the media to be meeting with the “government” of Ukraine is also ridiculous – Ukraine has a government and a President who, however unpopular, was overthrown and the current “government” have not been elected by anybody. They need to be elected before they can have any legitimacy. On the other hand I do see the West's concern with Putin - who seems to develop more dictatorial tendencies every year he is in power. They clearly want to send a message to him that they won't allow him to go any further - but I just don't see him backing down on Crimea, nor the West doing anything about it so my point is that this is probably not the fight to pick with him - but if the real reason is to stop him going further down the road and trying to annex another territory, that's another story.
Posted by Michael de Broglio on Thursday 27-Mar-14
Post a Comment
Comments
Elektra said:
on Friday 28-Mar-14 03:36 PM
Safia, I couldn't agree wit you more. The people have the right to vote, but if they keep voting for the same President, nothing will change.
Sorea said:
on Thursday 27-Mar-14 02:38 PM
If it is what they want then so be it. But there is still the old adage ... be careful what you wish for.
Safia said:
on Thursday 27-Mar-14 01:54 PM
Putin is a dictator. but they say every nation deserves their president.If Russians want to be slaves and have no democracy, then be it, let them vote for him.Until Russians all stand up and speak up against one man's rule, nothing will change. Putin's recent law to make homosexuality illegal just shows tendency to tzar's actions as much as Crimea.When the whole world accepting homosexuality, he says he will put gays to prison.So stupid.
Zelda said:
on Thursday 27-Mar-14 09:16 AM
i did some research on this and they say that a war with Russia, at least under existing circumstances, may be costly and very troublesome and if Russia be obstinate when defeated, it may continue longer than the people expect...
I agree with Jade, if it's fair and the people ask for it... then that is what they should get
Jade said:
on Thursday 27-Mar-14 08:41 AM
It was said that pro-russian parties were using scare-tactics to force people into voting to break away from Ukraine whilst others who do not wish to become part of Russia were boycotting the vote completely. However, perhaps this is just western news trying to convince the world that their sanctions are justified.
Apparently Crimea is an good strategic point for the army and navy for Russia. Perhaps this is why the other world powers are so nervous.
But I have to agree, if it was fairly voted and that is what the people want, then let them be.
Johannesburg based attorney specializing in personal injury matters including Road Accident Fund claims and medical negligence matters. My interests include golf, reading and the internet and the way it is constantly developing. I have a passion for life and a desire for less stress!