Attorney Michael de Broglio on: South Africa, Law, Politics, Attorneys, Sport, Photography, Technology, Gadgets, Media, Crime, Road Accidents Fund,
Divorce, Maintenance, Personal Injury, Medical Negligence
The Eternal Road is an Indie film or independent movie that I recently watched during a film festival. It deals with a forgotten part of Russia’s past and that is when in the time of Stalin workers from around the world were invited to come and join in the socialist revolution that was taking place in Russia. The Russian government placed adverts in newspapers around the world encouraging the workers of the world to come to Russia for plentiful jobs and because there were no jobs in their countries, and they felt they could not look after their families, or because they believed in socialism, they took up those offers. This is also very well covered in a book called “The Forsaken, an American tragedy in Stalin’s Russia” by Tim Tzouliadis. The theme of the book is pretty much the same as that of the movie and I would strongly suggest to anybody, particularly those with Russian origin or Russian members of their family, that they watch the movie. It relates to what happened to those people.
Initially, and in the late 1920s America went through a terrible recession, life for those particular people was far better in Russia, because many of them were unemployed in America. More than 10,000 Americans went to try out the excitement of the new experiment with socialism in Russia and many Finnish people went as well – the protagonist in the movie is Finnish. They were put on collective farms, they even had baseball games and social gatherings in Russia, but a few years later, during the late 1930s, Stalin became paranoid of many of these people, especially when they start wanting to go back to America, believing they were Russian spies. Their passports were confiscated and those that went to the American Embassy to try and make arrangements to get back were picked up by the secret police of Russia as soon as they left the Embassy and never seen again. The vast majority were shipped off, put on trucks and led to wooded areas where they were executed, one after another. That is where the title of the book comes in, because they were forsaken and in some instances their children were adopted by other Russians and given a new life, but more than 10,000 Americans and Finnish people as well as people from other countries of the world were simply executed.
It is a good reminder, while capitalism is not perfect, that communism and socialism have not worked in other countries and it was not just 20 million Russians who were killed during this time, but other people from all over the world who went along to genuinely take part in a political system that they thought was much better and had equality for all people, also got executed. For some reason or other the political systems that allege equality between people almost always end up, not only in disaster, but killing anybody along the road that dissents with them, disagrees with them or is even considered to be too intellectual for the system. The first to be killed are normally the lawyers, the Judges, the writers, the thinkers and many of those who were not executed learned very quickly to give up any job of any prestige at all and quickly become a labourer, farmer, etc.
Unfortunately for the Americans and the Finnish, who were largely working on farms as farmers, they just got executed. Movies and books like this often never make the mainstream with the result that most people, including most Russians, would not even know this history of their country because it is largely being covered up and forgotten about.
Posted by Michael de Broglio on Monday 02-Jul-18
Post a Comment
Comments
Tersia said:
on Thursday 02-Aug-18 07:29 AM
I never knew about this. I don't really watch or read about historical events, I like more to read and watch true events that has to do with murder and crime. But I guess you can say that this is the same as people were murdered for just being something different to what they wanted. I will try to read the book, books always have more detail.
Cornelie said:
on Wednesday 01-Aug-18 04:24 PM
I would love to watch the movie, I love history and how things were back in the day in any country will definitely watch the movie.
Sinead said:
on Wednesday 01-Aug-18 09:14 AM
I was never a big history fan in school. As time goes by you realize how important it is to know about these kinds of events. This is very interesting and sad at the same time. I would definitely like to read more about it, that's for sure.
Jadine Richards said:
on Monday 30-Jul-18 03:52 PM
Just another example that the grass is not always greener on the other side. This is really sad especially considering that these victims went to Russia with so much hope and optimism. I think it is not only the particular political regime but also the fact that Stalin was pure evil.
Helen said:
on Monday 30-Jul-18 10:57 AM
This is so true, that so many historical facts we still do not know. I still remember studding history in Ukraine about Stalin and his 5 year plan, I can not recall that Russian book was stating facts like that: 799,455 known executions, over a million deaths in labor camps, and over 390,000 deaths due to forced relocation of the poorer elements of society. At least 6 million people died in the Ukrainian famine in 1932.
American historian Timothy D. Snyder has concluded that between 6 million and 9 million people died under Stalin’s reign of terror.
Henrietta said:
on Monday 30-Jul-18 10:46 AM
I have to agree with Michelle D, it sad that you have to have history until matric to learn about this kind of history, I would have enjoyed this history in school. This blog was truly interesting to read. I didn't even know about this or Stalin until this blog and want to know more therefore the movie will definitely be watch.
Zindy said:
on Friday 27-Jul-18 08:56 AM
I love movies that are based on true events, Not only educational but just knowing that it actually happened captivates me my attention. When I have an opportunity I will definitely watch it.
Nikita said:
on Friday 27-Jul-18 08:47 AM
I love movies like this. They are normally gut-wrenching but eye opening. Although it is historical there are still things like this happening all over the world. It always fascinates me how things are kept on the down low.
Ashleigh said:
on Friday 20-Jul-18 01:38 PM
This is a film that I would def watch. I really enjoy watching True Story Films. Even though sometimes you can be highly emotional afterwards, you atleast have been educated with what transpires / transpired in other countries.
brumilde said:
on Friday 20-Jul-18 01:25 PM
I will def add this in my list of movies to watch, i love the history films that come out, that shows part of history. Things people were not aware. One of my favorite ones although it is more a documentary is ' The greatest story never told' about Adolf Hitler. 5+ hours.
Prishani said:
on Thursday 19-Jul-18 04:44 PM
I thoroughly enjoy watching movies about history and wars and the feelings of people at the time these events took place and what actually transpired during these significant moments in history. It is always tragic to see but it does give one a sense of belonging and definitely a better understanding about how things were in the past.
Angelique Jurgens said:
on Thursday 19-Jul-18 04:42 PM
It is exceptionally sad that these things have happened but incredibly important that people know the true facts of the situation. It definitely sounds like an unsettling movie that would be heavy on my heart. Nonetheless, movies that do not make it mainstream should be watched, especially when the movie will raise emotions. You can kill a person, goes the old saying, but you can’t kill an idea.
Jessica said:
on Thursday 12-Jul-18 03:53 PM
This is what happened in the Soviet Union during the Great Terror, also known as the the Great Purge. The Great Purge refers to the political terror and repression that engulfed the Soviet Union under Joseph Stalin from 1936 to 1938. The purpose for the Great Purge - is allegedly Stalin's paranoia toward any opposition. It has also been recorded that a significant number of those 'thinker' or persons that were abducted were sent to labor camps, particularly within Serbia. Such a pivotal piece of history that should never be swept under the rug. Will certainly make a point of watching this film! 'Rotten Tomatoes' which is a film critic, has noted that the leader actor left audiences wanting, and was not able to fulfill the role? Hmmm
Sarah said:
on Tuesday 10-Jul-18 04:04 PM
I really thought Russian was a strong country but was you learn the history they are actually a poor country. There is also good actors and actresses acting in this movie
Brenda Du Toit said:
on Tuesday 10-Jul-18 08:43 AM
Sounds like a very interesting movie.I will definitely look out for it in future.True Stories is very interesting to watch
Joyce said:
on Friday 06-Jul-18 01:17 PM
Sounds like a very interesting movie, with important information to learn from. What started happening in Russia in 1930s it’s so sad, people forced not to go back to their countries, being executed and killed.
Suvashnee said:
on Friday 06-Jul-18 08:48 AM
This sounds like a very interesting movie with a lot of heart break as well as an eye opener.
Michelle D said:
on Thursday 05-Jul-18 05:42 PM
The Russian economic revolution under Stalin is very interesting, it's quite sad that you have to take history to matric to learn about Stalin's 5 year plan and the atrocities that took place in Russia. Before learning about it I had always assumed Russians were the good guys, liberating those oppressed in Germany after WWII. I was very wrong. Because of the censorship imposed on Russia, we don't even know the full scale of the horrors that went on there. Russia is too poor a country for something like communism to work in, communism would only work in an ideal world where greed didn't exist and there were such extensive economic resources that everyone could live a happy life without fear of poverty.
Daniella said:
on Thursday 05-Jul-18 11:06 AM
Definitely going to add this onto my 'must watch list' Its so important to the the history of a Country and some stories are just pushed under the metaphorical rug.
Mathilda said:
on Thursday 05-Jul-18 10:29 AM
I really enjoy movies that are based on true events and you actually learn something from it.
Will definitely make time to watch this
Liz said:
on Thursday 05-Jul-18 09:19 AM
I love these Indie movies, they feel slightly more real and relatable. I will definitely watch this movie as I enjoy movies that actually teach you something about the past. It is sad but so true that those in power turn on the people that supported them in the beginning and misuse their power - just like what happened in the allegorical novel Animal Farm by George Orwell.
Tamaryn said:
on Wednesday 04-Jul-18 05:27 PM
Absolute power corrupts absolutely. I think we scarcely know the true extent of what leaders in power have done over the years, and continue to do. Power in the wrong hands is dangerous, even deadly.
Megan said:
on Monday 02-Jul-18 11:33 AM
If you are interested in learning more about the world around you and the reason for certain occurrences, I do believe knowing the history of countries is important as per the saying "History tends to repeat itself"... Not saying this would happen within a good amount of years, its just best to be aware of circumstances countries went through to get to where they are.
Fikile said:
on Monday 02-Jul-18 10:09 AM
It sounds like a very educational book and for the fact that it's a true story makes it more and more interesting can't wait for the movie
Natasha said:
on Monday 02-Jul-18 09:34 AM
Sounds like a awesome movie will definitely look out for the movie. True stories are always so nice to watch
Clare said:
on Monday 02-Jul-18 09:13 AM
This sound like a good movie something that is true and like watching movies base on a True Story but when I comes to the killing parts i get very angry and i cry so i don't always like watching movies like this.
Alexis said:
on Monday 02-Jul-18 09:07 AM
Sounds like a very good movie and it is always something to learn about other places and their history- no country is perfect
Bianca N said:
on Monday 02-Jul-18 08:58 AM
This sounds like a very interesting movie to watch, whether you are of Russian origin or not. I will definitely look out for it in future.
Nicolle said:
on Monday 02-Jul-18 07:51 AM
Couple the suggested with: "Two legs good, four legs bad." turned: "Four legs bad, two legs good" - Animal Farm.
Animal farm, is told from the perspective of the common animals (‘people’) as a whole – gullible, loyal, hardworking. This gives one an idea as to how situations of oppression arise not only from the motives and tactics of the oppressors, but, also from the naiveté of the oppressed, who are not necessarily in a position to better educated or informed. An absolute brilliant piece of political satire.
That being said, I was sold when seeing the movie poster. To understands ones future, you should not forget the past.
Johannesburg based attorney specializing in personal injury matters including Road Accident Fund claims and medical negligence matters. My interests include golf, reading and the internet and the way it is constantly developing. I have a passion for life and a desire for less stress!