Attorney Michael de Broglio on: South Africa, Law, Politics, Attorneys, Sport, Photography, Technology, Gadgets, Media, Crime, Road Accidents Fund,
Divorce, Maintenance, Personal Injury, Medical Negligence
I had quite a hair-raising experience at Serengeti Golf Course, which I have written about quite favourably before on this blog, when playing a round of golf recently with friends. In short, their lightning system failed, and so it did not automatically trigger the sirens that usually go off around the golf course, when a storm starts approaching, with the result that we had a lightning bolt land approximately 100 metres away from us, terrifying the life out of the American friend with whom I was playing.
Worse still, when we got to the Pro Shop and tried to understand why the siren had not gone off, we were told that the automatic siren was broken, and the person working in the Pro Shop could not turn on the system manually because he was under strict orders that he is never to leave the Pro Shop and he had nobody else to help him because the golf director was playing a round of golf. So, instead of running upstairs and triggering a siren that would let people know immediately across 18 different holes and stretching over approximately 6 kilometres of golf course, that they should come in because it was certainly not safe to be playing, he came up with a new plan. The new plan, and this obviously satisfied the requirements for the Pro Shop, involved risking another employee’s life by sending him out on the golf course to drive from one hole to another to warn everybody on the golf course – a job which must have taken him at least 20 minutes, because that is how long it took for all the golfers, who were on the course, to stop arriving at the Clubhouse. In fact, by the time most of them arrived at the Clubhouse, the storm already passed over.
I don’t think Clubs, and perhaps the employees that they have at the Club on a Sunday afternoon when they are probably short-staffed, appreciate the financial risks that the Club would face in the event that the lightning struck the wrong four-ball, with for example, successful businessmen with young children, and killed them. You could quite easily be looking at payouts in excess of R100 million if you took out the wrong two golfers, and I am not sure one’s insurance policy would cover you if you had safety devices but you did not make sure that they were operational and your employees decided not to trigger them manually, because they had to keep the Pro Shop open and nobody was allowed to leave it. Whatever the risks of loss of profit of sales of 5 minutes on a quiet Sunday afternoon, or of a dishonest golfer or staff member running in and stealing a few items, or indeed the entire contents of the till, they would pale into insignificance compared to having one of your clients die, because you cannot be sensible.
Posted by Michael de Broglio on Tuesday 04-Jan-11
Post a Comment
Comments
David said:
on Wednesday 12-Jan-11 10:51 AM
Can you just imagine if someone was hurt. Peter would have some explaining to do. Such a silly risk to have taken, certainly not with his own life.
David John said:
on Wednesday 12-Jan-11 10:40 AM
What Peter is thinking of is a motor car, which is effectively a 'faraday cage'. If a car is struck by lightning, or subjected to any electrical current, the people inside (so long as they do not touch any metal parts) would not be subjected to the elctrical current. A golf cart, which is open, would offer no such protection.
Golf courses are large open areas, and generally the club house is quite far away - often kilometers. to not have a functioning storm siren is extremely dangerous. Imagine you had to run 4km or so back to the club house with lightining strikes around you...
Z Mbatha said:
on Wednesday 12-Jan-11 10:38 AM
Let me guess Peter is a white man and the individual he sent around in the lightening storm was a black man? Would love to be wrong but quite sure I am right. Fools, there is a reason the warning system exists. Its not for Peter to decide if its dangerous or not. If the warning should have gone off then its very simple IT SHOULD HAVE GONE OFF!!!
Gareth said:
on Wednesday 12-Jan-11 10:24 AM
Absolutely foolish! Would love to know exactly what turnover the pro shop did in those 20 minutes that was worth risking fatalities. It's as stupid as not wearing your seatbelt or using child seats and you know what they say only pumpkins don't buckle up.
Michael said:
on Monday 10-Jan-11 03:24 PM
Peter, its a fallacy that carts offer protection against lightning. the offer none at all. I think you have also missed the point that in order to make sure they suffered no theft in the shop they risked not only the life of their employee who they sent out but that of all golfers - it took them 20 minutes to alert some of them instead of tripping the alarm manually.
You seem to be more interested in having a "go" at people than actually reading what is written and commenting on it.
Preley said:
on Monday 10-Jan-11 02:58 PM
Sounds like to me someone had a bad round of golf and wants to blame the weather.
I Thought Serengeti was stunning, and personally I feel lightning sirons/warning systems are a last resort common sense should prevail long before, and for all the lazy golfers on carts it's easy and safe to get off the course on a cart ..... try walking !!!
Peter said:
on Monday 10-Jan-11 02:35 PM
Too be quite honest if people are dumb enough to stay out in a thunder storm, and not have the common sense to get off the course maybe natural selection is nescessary to get them out the Gene pool, Succesful bussiness man or not !!!
Enjoy the game, and stop winging no one forced you to carry on playing
PS: A golf cart is probably one of the safest places you can be in
Edwin Stafford-Nrthcote said:
on Monday 10-Jan-11 01:35 PM
I think that the lighting is such a low risk, and that driving in your car, doing any extreme sport is far more dangerous, smoking kills more people in 1 day than lighting will in hundred years. So why arent we so concern about those threats. But when first little blits happens then we jump. I happy to play in lighting, because I know where I am going when I die.
sAFIA said:
on Saturday 08-Jan-11 12:37 PM
This is so dangerous , look what happened in KZN , in one go family of 9 was killed by lightning , i guess it is even more dangerous to be riding a golf cart during a thunder storm
Johannesburg based attorney specializing in personal injury matters including Road Accident Fund claims and medical negligence matters. My interests include golf, reading and the internet and the way it is constantly developing. I have a passion for life and a desire for less stress!